Which would you rather get? Suede Boots or Leather Boots?

You can't go wrong with brown or black, and grey would be cool because you don't see it as much. All are neutral colors that go with anything, so I would concentrate more on the actual style of the boot. The important question is...are you hard on your boots/shoes? Suede is a lot harder to keep clean and does not wear and tear as well as leather. I always get many more years out of my leather boots than my suede boots. Suede tends to change color and show damage on the toe and heel, even if you use shockguard or some other weatherproofing spray (which I highly recommend if you do choose the suede.) So, if you beat on your stuff, definitely go with leather. I personally think leather looks dressier and clier so if that is your goal, definitely leather.